Trusted Local News

What to Do If You Receive a Mismatched Income Report at Tax Time

  • News from our partners

Tax season is challenging enough without the added confusion of receiving a tax document that doesn’t align with your records. Whether you’re a freelancer, small business owner, or employee, getting a mismatched income report can be stressful. You might come across a Form 1099-NEC, 1099-K, W-2, or even a Form 1099 DA that inflates your income, shows duplicate payments, or lists earnings you never actually received.

This article will explain what causes mismatched income reports, why they occur, and the important steps you should take to resolve discrepancies and protect yourself from unnecessary tax liabilities or IRS audits.

What Is a Mismatched Income Report?

A mismatched income report occurs when the amount listed on an income reporting form does not align with what you actually earned or reported. These forms are submitted to both you and the IRS, so any discrepancies can raise red flags and trigger automatic IRS notices or audits.

Common mismatches include:

  • Overstated income (e.g., being reported for more money than you were paid)
  • Duplicate reporting (e.g., two forms reporting the same income)
  • Incorrect taxpayer name or identification number
  • Misclassified employment (e.g., being issued a 1099 when you were an employee)
  • Income attributed to the wrong year

Why Do Income Reporting Errors Happen?

These errors can result from simple mistakes or systemic problems, including:

Clerical errors: Data entry mistakes, rounding errors, or copying wrong numbers.

Software issues: Some accounting programs may generate duplicate forms if not used correctly.

Vendor or employer confusion: Sometimes, companies aren’t clear on who qualifies as a contractor versus an employee.

Incorrect TIN or SSN: If a taxpayer identification number is mistyped, income might be linked to the wrong person.

Third-party processor mistakes: Platforms like PayPal or Stripe may report your earnings via 1099-K even if you've already been reported on a 1099-NEC.

First Steps: Stay Calm and Verify

Before you make any calls or file a complaint, take a deep breath and follow these steps:

Gather Your Own Records

Locate your invoices, payment receipts, bank statements, contracts, and any prior correspondence. Create a spreadsheet or list that shows exactly what you received, from whom, and when.

Review the Form Carefully

Double-check your name and Social Security Number (or EIN).

Look at the amount listed and compare it with your records.

Confirm the payer’s information and determine whether you actually worked for or received payments from them.

Sometimes the issue isn’t the amount, but the payer reporting under an unexpected business name or address.

Common Scenarios and What to Do

Scenario 1: Income Overstated 

If you received more than one 1099-NEC for the same job or the amount is too high:

  • Contact the payer immediately to ask for clarification.
  • If they agree there’s an error, they should issue a corrected 1099-NEC (marked “Corrected” at the top).
  • Wait until the corrected form is issued before filing your taxes.
  • Keep documentation of your communication in case the issue isn’t resolved quickly.

Scenario 2: You Received a 1099-K and a 1099-NEC for the Same Payments

This often happens to freelancers or small businesses who get paid through a platform like PayPal, Venmo, or Stripe. The client may issue a 1099-NEC, but the platform also reports the payment on a 1099-K.

  • Determine if the income was double-reported.
  • Include the total income on your tax return, but only once—you may need to attach an explanatory statement showing how you arrived at the correct number.
  • If the client shouldn't have issued a 1099-NEC for a payment processed via a third-party platform, you can ask them to correct it.

Scenario 3: You Didn’t Receive the Income at All

In rare cases, you might receive a 1099 or W-2 for income you never actually received.

This could be due to an error or identity theft.

Notify the payer immediately to resolve the issue and request a corrected form. If identity theft is suspected, contact the IRS Identity Protection Specialized Unit (IPSU) and consider filing Form 14039 (Identity Theft Affidavit).

Scenario 4: You Were Misclassified

If you worked as an employee but received a 1099 instead of a W-2, this is a worker misclassification issue.

  • Contact your employer and ask them to correct the form.
  • If they refuse, file Form SS-8 with the IRS to determine your proper worker status.
  • You may still file Form 8919 to report uncollected Social Security and Medicare taxes.

Reporting the Correct Income on Your Return

When you can’t resolve the issue before the tax deadline, you may still need to file. Here's how:

Report What You Actually Earned

Always report the income you truly received—even if it’s different from what was reported to the IRS.

Attach an Explanation

Attach a statement of explanation (in PDF or paper form) to your return that includes:

  • What form was incorrect
  • What the correct amount should be
  • Your supporting documentation
  • Any efforts you’ve made to correct it

Consider Filing Paper Instead of E-File

E-filing can be tricky when your documents don’t match the IRS system. In such cases, filing by mail gives you room to explain discrepancies.

Protecting Yourself in the Future

Mismatched income forms can derail your tax season, but there are ways to prevent or catch errors early:

  • Request W-9s upfront when paying or being paid as a contractor
  • Keep a detailed ledger of all payments you receive throughout the year
  • Reconcile your income against 1099s and W-2s as soon as you receive them in January
  • Communicate clearly with vendors or clients about how they plan to report your payments
  • If you’re paying others, submit accurate 1099s and review them before sending

When to Call a Tax Professional

If the issue isn’t resolved quickly or if you’re unsure how to handle it, it’s wise to consult a professional. They can help you file your return correctly, draft IRS explanations, and represent you if a dispute arises.

Handling Income Discrepancies with Confidence: Stay Calm, Stay Compliant

Receiving a mismatched income report is frustrating - but it doesn’t have to derail your tax season. By staying organized, communicating promptly, and documenting your actions, you can protect yourself from paying more than you owe and reduce your chances of an IRS audit.

Always remember: the IRS expects taxpayers to act in good faith. If you report what you earned honestly and make a clear effort to resolve discrepancies, you’re far more likely to emerge from tax season unscathed.

author

Chris Bates

MORE NEWS STORIES


STEWARTVILLE

JERSEY SHORE WEEKEND

LATEST NEWS

Events

July

S M T W T F S
29 30 1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 1 2

To Submit an Event Sign in first

Today's Events

No calendar events have been scheduled for today.